
A lawsuit was filed against outgoing California Gov. Gavin Newsom on Monday over his decision to issue a mass commutation for everyone on the state’s death row.
The New York Times reports that the suit was filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, a nonprofit group focused on victims’ rights, along with district attorneys from 30 of California’s 58 counties. The suit alleges that Newsom abused his power and violated several laws regarding death row commutations.
Earlier this month, Newsom announced he would commute the sentences of everyone on death row to life without parole. While this was a move he was mulling over, the botched execution of Christa Pike seemed to sway his decision-making. Newsom seemed to see this outcome coming, as while he defended his decision as the moral choice, he acknowledged that the move would “anger and hurt some Californians” in his statement announcing the move.
“I am acting on my long and deeply held conviction that individually and collectively we are stronger as a society when we reject state-sanctioned killing,” Newsom wrote in the letter announcing his decision.
One point of contention in the lawsuit is that families of the victims weren’t given notice before Newsom announced the mass commutations. “A mass clemency is inconsistent with a scheme designed to create a public process that ensures that all relevant information is considered regarding the individual crime and criminal,” the lawsuit says.
California law allows a governor to unilaterally commute a sentence if the person is convicted of a felony in a single case. If a person has several felony convictions, the governor must ask the state Supreme Court for approval of the commutation. Newsom is still waiting on the state Supreme Court to decide on whether 382 incarcerated people will receive a commutation. If Newsom’s commutation is ultimately approved, it will be the largest mass commutation in American history.
The plaintiffs believe some of the nearly 200 other people Newsom commuted may have multiple felony sentences, and they are asking the state Supreme Court to hold off on deciding until all cases can be thoroughly vetted.
“Governor Newsom decided his personal views should override all those who actually participated in the process, followed and applied the law. He did none of that, as he freely admits. That alone is an abuse of power that must not stand,” the petition said.
There has been a divided response over Newsom’s decision among family members of the victims. Dueling news conferences were held on the day Newsom announced the commutation, with one group approving the decision and another against.
Those who supported the decision said that executing the incarcerated wouldn’t bring them healing, and that they would rather see the state provide more support and resources for victims of violence. Those against the move were appalled that the people who murdered their loved ones could receive mercy, and said Newsom’s decision did nothing but reopen old wounds.
The decision to commute their sentences was largely symbolic. Newsom introduced a moratorium on executions in 2019, and governor-elect Xavier Becerra has said he will honor the moratorium.
SEE ALSO:

Comments are closed